jump to navigation

The Guards’ Report November 18, 2018

Posted by flashbuzzer in Books, Christianity.
Tags: , , , ,
add a comment

Here are my thoughts on Matthew 28:11-15.

Summary: In this passage, some of the guards report back to the chief priests after regaining consciousness. The Sanhedrin is then convened officially and passes a formal resolution, which entails:

  • giving silver money to the guards
  • instructing them to lie about the resurrection by asserting that while they were asleep, Jesus’ disciples stole His body
  • promising that if this news reaches Pilate, then the Sanhedrin will 1) satisfy him and 2) make the guards without anxiety.

The guards follow their instructions, and the Jews are convinced by their story for at least thirty years.

Thoughts: Here, the Jewish elites instruct the Roman guards to lie about the resurrection. Their actions raise several questions, including:

  • did the Jewish elites believe that Jesus actually rose from the dead?
  • were the Jewish elites (privately) convinced that Jesus was the Son of God?
  • did the Roman guards entertain any doubts about their instructions?
  • how did Matthew learn about this act of collusion between the Sanhedrin and the guards?
  • did a member of the Sanhedrin – or a guard – accidentally reveal the details of this plot to Matthew (or a trusted source)?
  • did any of the guards repent of their lie concerning the resurrection?
  • did Pilate remain ignorant of the news concerning the resurrection?

While I long to travel back in time and interview the Roman guards, the impossibility of that act compels me to trust in the veracity of this passage.

Advertisements